Elon Musk’s freedom from consequences is once again denied.

Elon Musk's X Corp. has hit a snag trying to block California's AB 587, a law that aims to clean up the online environment by requiring transparency in content moderation.

Peter Blumberg and Malathi Nayak in Bloomberg

In an eight-page ruling Thursday, a federal judge in Sacramento rejected arguments by the company formerly known as Twitter that the measure violates the free-speech rights of social media platforms.

The ruling comes after Musk ignited a firestorm in November by endorsing antisemitic posts on his platform. X Corp. Chief Executive Officer Linda Yaccarino scrambled to contain the fallout after major advertisers like Sony, Discovery, Apple and CBS stopped or paused spending on the site.

Look. Moderating a massive social platform is a tough ask. It’s fraught with complexities that mirror the labyrinthine nature of human behaviour and the inherent messiness of our interactions, amplified by the veil of anonymity that the internet so generously provides. People, when cloaked in this digital invisibility, unleash aspects of their persona that might never surface in face-to-face interactions. They become bolder, crossing into the realms of cruelty and aggression, safe in the knowledge that there are few immediate, tangible repercussions to their online conduct.

The lines of what is and isn't acceptable speech are nebulous. What one individual perceives as a harmless joke, another might view as a deeply personal attack. This subjective variability turns content moderation into a balance between protecting free speech and preventing harm. The rapid evolution of online slang, memes, and symbols adds another layer of complexity, leaving moderators scrambling to keep up with the mutating lexicon of the internet.

Grey areas don't only get greyer; they multiply. The platforms face dilemmas that were unimaginable a couple of decades ago. Should a comment inciting political violence be treated the same as one spreading misinformation about health? How does one weigh the merits of controversial but newsworthy content against the potential harm it might cause? These questions don't have easy answers, but they demand a response.

Social media platforms, particularly those with user bases numbering in the millions or even billions, wield immense power over public discourse. They have become places where ideas are exchanged, movements are born, and societies are shaped. The responsibility of content moderation cannot be shrugged off.

Ignoring this responsibility or addressing it half-heartedly will have far-reaching consequences. Unchecked platforms become breeding grounds for hate speech, misinformation, and harmful propaganda, with real-world consequences that range from individual harm to societal division. Yes, the task of moderation is undoubtedly Sisyphean. But it’s also non-negotiable and essential.

No platform will ever perfectly navigate the dangers of online discourse. But striving for a balanced, thoughtful approach to content moderation is both a service to their users and a duty to our larger social fabric. And a pragmatic and transparent approach to content moderation is the only logical step. Content moderation doesn't amount to curtailing free speech but rather ensures that a platform doesn't become a free-for-all.


My favourite part of the debacle is Musk blaming watchdog groups for a slump in advertising revenue, claiming they're spreading false accusations. It couldn't be the result of his own decisions, right?

The irony of a self-proclaimed "free speech absolutist," complaining about a decline in advertising revenue due to the platform's toxicity is hard to miss. It's a classic case of wanting to have one's hate-baiting cake and eat it, too. Like most users, the reality is that advertisers prefer a platform that feels like something other than a battleground.


Sign up with your email address to receive the weekly Joan’s Index email.

Email Address

Sign Up

I respect your privacy. And I don’t platform Nazis.

Thank you!

@Westenberg logo
Subscribe to @Westenberg and never miss a post.